Active 1 / 39
Front exterior — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 2 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 3 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 4 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 5 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Active
4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 1 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 2 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 3 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 4 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 5 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 6 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 7 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 8 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 9 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 10 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 11 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 12 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 13 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 14 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 15 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 16 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 17 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 18 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 19 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 20 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 21 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 22 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 23 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 24 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 25 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 26 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 27 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 28 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 29 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 30 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 31 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 32 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 33 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 34 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 35 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 36 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 37 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 38 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065
Photo 39 — 4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065

Newcastle, OK 73065

$430,000

4418 S May Avenue, Newcastle, OK 73065

3 BD · 2 BA · 1,914 sq ft · Built 1979

$225
per sq ft
0
days listed
5
acre lot
4-car
garage
Type
Single Family Residence
Year built
1979
Garage
4-car attached
School district
Newcastle
MLS #
1253880

Enjoy the best of country living with modern comforts on 5 beautiful acres in Newcastle! This fully remodeled 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers updated finishes throughout, spacious living areas, and a cozy wood-burning fireplace. The property features an attached 4-car garage, an additional detached garage, and a barn with stalls, making it ideal for horse enthusiasts, livestock owners, or anyone looking for room to spread out. The fully fenced acreage includes a continuous water trough system and plenty of open space for animals, hobbies, or outdoor activities. Conveniently located at the corner of Highway 9 and May Avenue, you’ll enjoy easy access to Newcastle, Norman, and the Oklahoma City metro while still having the privacy and freedom of country living. Whether you’re dreaming of your own hobby ranch, need space for your toys and equipment, or simply want a beautifully remodeled home with acreage, this property has so much to offer! *Home is currently an Airbnb

Listed for sale
Oct 14, 2026

History from MLS records since this home was listed.

Monthly cost

— / month

Principal, interest, taxes, insurance, and HOA.

Principal & interest
—
Property taxes
—
Home insurance
—
HOA
—

Planning estimate, not a quote. Rate and insurance are editable assumptions. Taxes can change after purchase; confirm HOA dues and their frequency. Mortgage insurance, closing costs, and maintenance are not included.

MLSOK Listing provided courtesy of Rachel Cosby, The Agency ((405) 216-3693). Status: Active.

Listings courtesy of MLSOK as distributed by MLS GRID.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of Oct 19, 2026, 10:02 PM CT. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website.

Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS, as established by the applicable MLS Governing Documents.

The listing information provided here is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Any use or search of this data other than by a consumer looking to purchase real estate is prohibited.

Data last updated Oct 19, 2026, 10:02 PM CT. MLS # 1253880. Homestead & Co is a licensed Oklahoma real estate brokerage.

$430,000

Phone is optional. By providing it, you agree Homestead & Co may call or text you about your inquiry (e.g. showing confirmations, follow-ups). Msg & data rates may apply; reply STOP to opt out, HELP for help. Consent is not a condition of any purchase or listing. SMS Terms · Privacy.

No account needed. If your agent is with a client, our client-care team picks up every request.

What's your home worth?
A range from real nearby sales — not an appraisal.
Get your estimate