Sold

76 photos coming soon

Broken Arrow, OK 74012

$489,900 Sold May 2026

1504 W Plymouth Circle, Broken Arrow, OK 74012

5 BD · 4 BA · 3,682 sq ft · Built 2003

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Select · Jeanette Bagrosky · (918) 496-3333

$133
per sq ft
4
days on market
0.33
acre lot
3-car
garage
Type
Residential
Year built
2003
Garage
3-car attached
HOA
$475 / yr
School district
Broken Arrow - Sch Dist (3)
MLS #
2614829

This previous builder-owned-home is in the gated area of Battle Creek Subdivision and comes wiith all the extras! Beautifully landscaped with rock/stone waterfall out front. Full brick/stone exterior w/large circle driveway. All new exterior paint - 2025! 5 beds, 3 1/2 baths, Designated Executive Office, Formal Living & Family Room, Formal Dining, Breakfast Nook, Game Room & Covered Patio w/extended Tamko Woodland Bark Deck (added May of 2017). 2 pergolas and a hot tub (hot tub stays!) 2 fireplaces! Oversized 3 car garage with storm shelter and loaded with storage! The office has wood paneling, built-in shelving/storage and a built-in desk plus room for a larger desk and/or couch/chairs. The formal dining is easily large enough for an 8-10 person table. The Formal Living has a fireplace w/wood accents and built-ins. The hallway has backlit built-in cabinetry (built-ins throughout the home!) The Family Room and Breakfast Nook have vaulted ceilings that carry through both spaces. Family Room also has a 2nd fireplace and is semi-open to the kitchen. Seller installed beautiful new granite countertops in 2017. Kitchen also has a built-in-hutch and most of the stainless steel appliances have been updated in the past few years. Double ovens! The Primary Bedroom has space for oversized/king-sized furniture. The primary bath has been remodeled to include a large walk-in shower, tiled floors, built-in storage, and more! 2nd and 3rd bedrooms downstairs have a full bath between them and there is another 1/2 bath downstairs as well. Good-sized laundry with sink and folding counter. 4th and 5th bedrooms are located upstairs along with a full bath and game room. Gutter helmet added by Rain Guard of Tulsa in 2017. New french drain with pump in 2026. New water tank in 2022. Backyard deck has 2 seating areas plus the hot tub area; very serene/peaceful but also great for entertaining! **Home has been pre-inspected for buyer's peace of mind with repairs disclosed. Broken Arrow Schools!

Sold$489,900
May 28, 2026
Listed for sale$489,900
Apr 24, 2026

History from MLS records since this home was listed.

Monthly cost

— / month

Principal, interest, taxes, insurance, and HOA.

Assumes a $489,900 price, 20% down, 30-year fixed rate at 7.28% (APR 7.28%). Includes taxes, insurance, and HOA dues; mortgage insurance not included. APR assumed equal to the rate; actual APR will be higher with lender fees. Estimate only. Not a loan offer or commitment.

An annual tax record is not available. This calculation starts with a planning allowance of 1.1% of the price. Adjust taxes below after confirming the amount with your lender or county assessor.

Principal & interest
—
Property taxes
—
Home insurance
—
HOA
—

Planning estimate, not a quote. Rate and insurance are editable assumptions. Taxes can change after purchase; confirm HOA dues and their frequency. Mortgage insurance, closing costs, and maintenance are not included.

Rate: Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey 30-year fixed average for the week of Nov 19, 2026, via FRED. An average, not a quote.

Insurance: about $5,800/yr for a $300,000 Oklahoma home, scaled by price (Oklahoma average, InsuranceNewsNet and Insurify 2026 studies). Your quote depends on the home, roof, deductible and insurer.

What will insurance cost on this home?

Get a free homeowners insurance quote from a licensed local agent.

Liberty Link Group · licensed insurance agency

Get a free quote

Affiliated Business Arrangement disclosure: Homestead & Co's owner has an ownership interest in Liberty Link Group, an insurance agency. Because of that relationship, this referral may provide the owner a financial or other benefit.

You are not required to use Liberty Link Group as a condition of buying, selling or owning any home. You are free to buy insurance from any agent or company you choose.

Homestead & Co and its agents are paid no fee for this referral.

Leave this unchecked and they will contact you by email only.

Liberty Link Group is a licensed Oklahoma insurance agency. A licensed agent will contact you.

A quote is not a policy or a binder. Coverage depends on the insurance company's review.

Your request also goes to your Homestead & Co agent. We share only what you type here plus the general price range you were looking at.

Get pre-approved

A local lender can tell you what you can borrow — free, and it does not commit you to anything.

Kurt Swink · Financial Concepts Mortgage

Get pre-approved

Relationship disclosure: Homestead & Co's owner is a licensed mortgage loan officer with Financial Concepts Mortgage. Because of that relationship, this referral may provide the owner a financial or other benefit.

You are not required to use Financial Concepts Mortgage or Kurt Swink. You are free to choose any lender, and shopping more than one lender may save you money.

Homestead & Co and its agents are paid no fee for this referral.

Leave this unchecked and they will contact you by email only.

Kurt Swink, NMLS #207515 · Financial Concepts Mortgage, NMLS #181632.

This is not a loan application, a rate quote, an offer of credit or a commitment to lend. Loan approval depends on the lender's review.

Equal Housing Opportunity.

Your request also goes to your Homestead & Co agent. We share only what you type here plus the general price range you were looking at.

Listing provided courtesy of Jeanette Bagrosky, Coldwell Banker Select · (918) 496-3333 · [email protected] . Status: Sold.

Listing information provided by MLS Technology, Inc. (Tulsa).

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Listing data last updated Jun 1, 2026, 12:12 PM CT. MLS # 2614829. Displayed by Homestead & Co, a licensed Oklahoma real estate brokerage.

$489,900 Sold May 2026

Phone is optional. By providing it, you agree Homestead & Co may call or text you about your inquiry (e.g. showing confirmations, follow-ups). Msg & data rates may apply; reply STOP to opt out, HELP for help. Consent is not a condition of any purchase or listing. SMS Terms · Privacy.

No account needed. If your agent is with a client, our client-care team picks up every request.

What's your home worth?
A range from real nearby sales — not an appraisal.
Get your estimate